Guided Tours vs. Booking on Your Own: Which Option Is Better?

Image: Machu Picchu, Peru.
Image: Machu Picchu, Peru.
Holly Johnson
by Holly Johnson
Last updated: 7:00 AM ET, Sun October 6, 2024

Even seasoned travelers can find planning trips to certain destinations overwhelming, even if they're accustomed to experiencing new cultures in countries they have never visited. This is especially the case when traveling somewhere incredibly remote or if a trip itinerary requires a ton of moving parts.

My husband and I found ourselves in this exact situation when deciding when and how to visit one of the seven wonders of the world — Machu Picchu in the country of Peru. Not only is Machu Picchu located in a remote part of Peru that's only accessible by a specific train and bus (unless you hike the Inca Trail), but you have to book separate time-stamped tickets for entry into the site, a bus ride through the mountains, the train to get there and more. Plus, we didn't know what else to do in Peru, or what kinds of additional sights we should pack into the same trip.

Ultimately, this is one of the reasons we opted for a guided tour of Peru called "Highlights of Peru," which is available through a guided tour company called Trafalgar. This specific tour included a range of sightseeing and activities throughout Peru, including a visit to Machu Picchu, a journey through Peru's Sacred Valley and a few days in Cusco, Peru.

Cost Comparison: Guided Tours vs. Booking On Your Own

One interesting fact I discovered about guided tours is their overall affordability, especially when you compare booking all the different components of a trip yourself. For example, the Highlights of Peru trip from Trafalgar is available for $2,630 per person over some dates, and this particular trip includes eight days of activities and personalized tours, a week of hotel stays, visits to four different cities, domestic flights, seven breakfasts, four dinners and two lunches.

Some of the inclusions of the trip were difficult to quantify in terms of cost, but I came up with the following estimates to see what the price would be to book some aspects of the trip on our own. 

Hotel stays: 

  • Three nights in Lima, Peru, at Iberostar Lima - $525 ($175 per night)
  • Two nights in Cusco, Peru, at Novotel Cusco - $400 ($200 per night)
  • One night at Sonesta Posadas del Inca Yucay, Sacred Valley - $125
  • One night in Machu Picchu town at El MaPi - $200

Flights: 

  • Lima to Cusco on LATAM Airlines with a checked bag: $150 (for two people)
  • Cusco to Lima on LATAM Airlines with a checked bag: $150 (for two people)

Meals:

  • Seven breakfasts - $350 ($25 per meal, per person)
  • Four dinners - $320 ($40 per meal, per person)
  • Two lunches - $160 ($40 per meal, per person)

Total: $2,380

Adding In the "Extras"

When you add those components of the trip together, the total reaches $2,380 - about half the cost for this specific Trafalgar tour for two people ($5,260). However, the trip also included other luxuries and "extras" that were hard to price out, including:

  • Bus transportation with a driver throughout Lima, Cusco and the Sacred Valley
  • Train transportation to Machu Picchu town, which is the gateway to Machu Picchu
  • Luggage handling during the entire trip
  • Flight handling (domestic)
  • Guided tour of Lima’s UNESCO-listed historic center
  • Lima, Peru, cooking school experience
  • Quechua weaving experience
  • Visit to llama and alpaca farm
  • Guided tour of Machu Picchu
  • Guided tour of Incan ruins in Ollantaytambo, Peru
  • Chicha (corn beer) making experience
  • Guided tour of Cusco, Peru
  • Guided tour of the Larco Museum back in Lima

These additional aspects of the trip were definitely worth the additional funds to me, especially considering the trip came with several intensive and interesting guided tours throughout Peru. Our tour guide had so many interesting stories to tell and insights to share. Plus, there were experiences we couldn't have possibly set up on our own - like when we learned how to make Peruvian corn beer and the visit to a remote llama and alpaca farm high up in the mountains above Cusco. The visit to Machu Picchu itself was also seamless, with our tour guide handing out perfectly timed tickets and passes as we needed them.

Machu Picchu, Peru.

Machu Picchu, Peru.

Also, luggage and flight handling are incredible benefits and are more important than they sound. Not only did we never have to move our luggage from hotel to hotel or to the airport, but we also never printed a boarding pass or luggage tags for our domestic flights. Trafalgar printed our boarding passes and tagged our luggage. All we had to do was show up when and where we were told.

Final Thoughts

Now that this trip is in the rearview mirror, I'm convinced that guided tours can be an exceptional deal in more ways than one. If we paid out of pocket for all aspects of the trip on our own, we would have forked over about the same amount in cash for all the hotel stays, flights, tours and meals we enjoyed. However, booking and planning ourselves would have been considerably more intensive and stressful. Having seen all the ins and outs of getting to Machu Picchu firsthand, I can't imagine going through all the steps without someone holding my hand.

The fact is, having someone take care of all the details was a lot more convenient than I could have imagined. The affordability aspect is also a major plus, but it's secondary to the fact we had more time to enjoy Peru without having to stress over all the details. 

At the end of the day, it seems like some trips are probably better on your own, whereas others work best when you leave it to the professionals. At the very least, it's worth doing a side-by-side cost comparison and deciding what you want the most.


For the latest travel news, updates and deals, subscribe to the daily TravelPulse newsletter.

Topics From This Article to Explore

Related Videos

Become A Travel Expert

Upcoming Webinar
2025 Travel Trends – How to Maximize Your SalesTuesday, December 17, 2024
2:00pm Eastern
Join us for a dynamic session where we’ll dive into the key travel trends shaping the industry in...
Upcoming Webinar
This is Windstar CruisesWednesday, December 18, 2024 2:00pm EasternLearn about all things Windstar and end the year with the tools to kick off an incredible 2025....
Upcoming Webinar
Kensington 2025 Travel Trends ReportFriday, December 20, 2024
2:00pm Eastern
Kensington is thrilled to announce that our 2025 Travel Trends Report is finally here – and we can’t...
Upcoming Webinar
2025 Travel Trends – How to Maximize Your SalesTuesday, December 17, 2024
2:00pm Eastern
Join us for a dynamic session where we’ll dive into the key travel trends shaping the industry in...
Upcoming Webinar
This is Windstar CruisesWednesday, December 18, 2024 2:00pm EasternLearn about all things Windstar and end the year with the tools to kick off an incredible 2025....
Upcoming Webinar
Kensington 2025 Travel Trends ReportFriday, December 20, 2024
2:00pm Eastern
Kensington is thrilled to announce that our 2025 Travel Trends Report is finally here – and we can’t...

Get To Know Us Better

Agent At Home

Helping leisure selling travel agents successfully manage their at-home business.

Subscribe For Free

Agent Specialization: Group Travel

Laurence Pinckney

Laurence Pinckney

CEO of Zenbiz Travel, LLC

About Me
Agent At Home

Helping leisure selling travel agents successfully manage their at-home business.

Subscribe For Free

Agent Specialization: Group Travel

Laurence Pinckney

Laurence Pinckney

CEO of Zenbiz Travel, LLC

About Me